Music as Therapy: A Dialogal Perspective
Reviews
Table of Contents

Reviews - Click to Read Review
Laurel Young, Nordic Journal of Music Therapy, Online Book Reviews, January 16, 2006.
Gary Ansdell in British Journal of Music Therapy, 21, 2007.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLES AND FIGURES x
PREFACE xi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS xiii
1. FRAME AND PICTURE
THE TERM “MUSIC THERAPY”
Music-centered Therapy
Analysis and Synthesis
Music Problems
THE NEED FOR VERBAL PROCESSING
Questioning the Need to Verbalize
“Psychodynamically Informed” Music Therapy
Recent Analytical Developments
DEVELOPMENT OF THEORY
Early Interaction Analogy
Not the same as Music
New Musicology
Health Musicking
The Meaning of Words and of Music
Clinical and Music-based Theories
Community Music Therapy
DIFFERENCES OF ASSUMPTIONS
General Theory
Recognizing and Accepting Difference
Indigenous and Imported Theory
Music-centered thinking
Insight and Transformative Therapies
Music as Therapy
Philosophy, Theory, and Practice
A Humanistic Foundation
A Dialogical Perspective

1
1
2
3
4
6
7
9
11
13
14
16
17
19
20
22
23
25
26
28
29
30
32
33
35
35
37

2. DIALOGUE
ORIGIN AND HISTORY OF THE CONCEPT
Two Historical Phases
MAIN TENETS
Three Spheres
Second Versus Third Person
Immediacy
Presence and Object
The Whole Being Involved
Encounter
Mutuality
Responsibility
Actuality and Latency
The Eternal You
COMMENTARY
Theology and Philosophy
The Problem of Intersubjectivity
Applications to Psychotherapy
On Freud’s Psychoanalysis
The Debate with Jung
Postmodern Themes
CRITICISMS
Explanation and Understanding
The Constructive Role of It
A WAY OF VIEWING
40
40
42
43
44
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
53
55
56
58
59
60
63
63
64
66
3. THE MUSIC THERAPY TRIAD
ENCOUNTER WITH MUSIC
Relating to, and Talking About
The Creative Encounter
The Work Acted Upon, and the Person
Artistic and Musicological Objectifications
THE MUSICAL WORK
Other Ontologies of Music
Music Embedded in Culture
Music, Therapist, and Client
MUSIC AS A MEANS
The Logic of Means and End
Playing the Piano for Some Other Purpose
A Counterexample
Treating Human Beings as Things
Humanistic Critique of Reification
Music as a “Physical Object”
THE MUSIC THERAPY TRIANGLE
An Illustrative Example: Annabel
Music as a Medium
A Medium for Therapy
Interpersonal and Musical Relational Fields
DIFFERENT SPHERES OF RELATION
68
68
71
72
73
74
75
76
78
78
79
81
81
82
83
85
86
89
90
95
95
97
102
4. RELATIONAL KNOWING 103
THE EARLY INTERACTION ANALOGY
The “Innate You”
Affect Attunement and Connection
Dynamic Form
Spoken and Heard
Change Processes in Therapy
IMPLICIT RELATIONAL KNOWING
The Moment of Meeting
Three Phases of Transition
Transference Issues Minimized
A Change that Happens
Psychodynamic and Humanistic Interdialogue
APPLICATION TO EXAMPLES FROM THE LITERATURE
The Example of David
The Example of Mathew
Relational Change
AN EXAMPLE FROM MY OWN PRACTICE: LISA
A Drum-Playing Incident
The Relationship Changed
A Meeting Through Music
103
103
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
116
117
118
119
121
122
124
126
127
5. RELATING TO MUSIC
COMING TO KNOW
Getting to Know Music
Change in the Relation to Music
CHANGE IN THE SENSE OF SELF
“Peak Experience”
Integrating the Experience
Incremental Changes
Musical Transference
RELATING THE INTERPERSONAL AND THE MUSICAL
Playing Together
“Communitas”
Two Intercrossing Lines
SUBSTITUTING WORDS WITH MUSIC
Dynamic and Aesthetic Form
Three Sides Interrelated, Across Two Spheres
Encounter With and Through Music
Music and Words
128
128
131
132
134
134
136
137
138
139
140
140
142
145
145
147
148
148
6. ROLES OF MUSIC, WAYS OF TALKING
COMPARING MODELS IDEAL-TYPICALLY
Creative Music Therapy
Analytical Music Therapy
“Referential” Improvisation
An Active Approach
Function versus Overall Change
Resolving Conflict
Resistiveness and Participation
Musical Progression
Words Facilitating Music
Music Translated
Music as a “World”
The Musical Relational Field
PROJECTION AND EXPRESSION
A Symbolic Projection
An Aesthetic Expression
Beyond the Individual
A “Hermeneutics of Suspicion”
An Example of Priestley’s
Reading the Client through Dynamic Form
VERBALIZATION REQUIREMENT
On the Possible Integration of the Perspectives
Shifting Between One and the Other
Different Roles, Different Plays
Differences within each Model Too
WAYS OF TALKING
A Confused Issue
Believing in what is said
149
149
151
154
155
156
157
157
158
158
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
168
169
170
172
173
174
176
178
180
180
182
182
7. A FORMED IMAGE IN SOUND
BUBER’S VIEW ON ART
The Perfected Image
On Music Specifically
“Image-Creation,” or Created Image
A DEFINITION OF MUSIC
Looking and Seeing, Listening and Hearing
The Aesthetic Object
The Ambiguity of the Image
How it Sounds as What is Said
Natural Qualities of Sound
Krenek’s definition
Musical Materials
The Perfected Image
Resemblance Potentials
A PHENOMENOLOGICAL ORIENTATION
The World Echoed
Multi-spectered Meaning
Related to as a Whole, by the Whole Person
“World Order” and “Ordered World”
MUSIC AS AN ACTIVITY
Relating to Music through Dance
Power to Engage
BEYOND AESTHETICS
184
184
186
188
188
189
191
192
192
194
195
197
198
199
202
202
204
205
207
209
211
213
214
215
8. OUTLINING A RATIONALE
PHILOSOPHICAL ANTHROPOLOGY
Return to Immediacy
Turning Toward the Other
Capacity to Relate
THE THERAPIST’S RESPONSIBILITY
Artistic and Therapeutic Imagination
The Notion of Empathy
A Therapeutic Pursuit
WORKING AND PLAYING
The Concept of Play
No Fixed Correspondence
Expression by Simple Means
The Whole Person Engaged
A Shared Momment
Gradual Development and Sudden Change
A Summary of the Therapeutic process
The example of Ole
The Two sides of Working and Playing
ENHANCING RESOURCES
No Specific Client Group
Repair and Regeneration
MUSICAL CHANGE AND PERSONAL CHANGE
What and How
Spirit and Grace
The Way of Playing
The Notion of Spirit
217
217
218
220
221
222
223
224
225
228
229
230
232
232
233
234
236
238
240
241
242
243
245
247
249
250
252
9. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE
A RESOURCE-ORIENTED APPROACH
Different Roads, Different Destinations
Transcending Limitations
Various Institutional Settings
Diagnosis and Assessment
Intervention versus Healing Practice
“Mis-matching” as “Clinical Intervention”
THERAPEUTIC TECHNIQUE
Idioms Facilitating Creativity
Idioms in Therapy
Relating Music to the Client
A Conversational Principle
An Image in the Likeness of
Aesthetic Properties
Musical Significance
Something Itself to Relate to
EXPRESSIVE RESOURCES
The Middle Eastern Scale as an example
The Power of the Response
THE POTENTIALS OF THE MOMENT
A Way
THE ASPECT OF CULTURE
Music and Identity
254
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
262
263
264
264
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
275
277
278
279
280
10. COMMUNITY-ORIENTED THERAPY
EXPANSIONS OF THE THERAPEUTIC SETTING
Communal Dialogue
PERFORMANCE-BASED APPROACH
The Issue of Confidentiality
Becoming Known
The Audience as an Additional Actor
Therapeutic Potentials of the Social Dimension
RETAINING A FOCUS ON THE PERSON
The Case of Josie
THERAPEUTIC CONTRACT
281
281
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
11. THE RECEPTIVE MODE
TRAVELER, GUIDE, MUSIC, AND IMAGERY
Two Approaches
Transference onto Music
RELATING DIRECTLY TO MUSIC
Using Classical Music
Listening Competency
On Knowing some Music
THERAPEUTIC PROCESS
The “Work” and the “Play”
Attending to the Traveler
Sharing in the Experience
AN EXAMPLE FROM A SESSION OF MY OWN
Music into the foreground
Outcome
AN OPTION OPENED FOR
Probing or Letting Be
PROCESSING THE EXPERIENCE
Not Reducing to Personal Conflict Matters
Other Modalities than Music in BMGIM
All Music Experience also Receptive
293
293
295
297
298
299
300
301
303
304
305
306
307
308
308
309
310
311
312
313
315
12. REMEMBERING AND FORGETTING
A THEORY FOR MUSIC AS MUSIC IN THERAPY
Verbalization Issue
An Aesthetics of Music for Music Therapy
The Therapeutic Relationship
A General Theory of Music as Therapy
THE BASIS FOR FURTHER DEVELOPMENT
Research and Reflexivity
Creative Development
An Ethical Basis
THEORY FOR REMEMBERING
Forgetting, for Direct Relation
A Paradox
316
316
317
318
319
319
320
321
322
322
323
324
324
REFERENCES 326